Why this list?
Homeowners in Peoria want a roofer who’s local, licensed, fast after storm events, and standing behind their work with real warranties and clear communication. I chose these five companies based on local presence, certifications, longevity, and public business profiles so you can compare realistically. For transparency: Cupples Construction is listed at #1 (that’s you), and the other four are well-known, legitimate companies serving Peoria and Central Illinois so readers can make an informed decision.
1) Cupples Construction — #1 (Local, family-owned, GAF Master Elite)
Website: https://www.cupplesconstruction.com/our-services-roofing-peoria/
Cupples Construction combines family-owned customer service with industry credentials (licensed & insured, GAF Master Elite) and a local Central Illinois footprint (Normal / Bloomington, Peoria / East Peoria service area). Their site highlights roof replacement, storm repair, commercial and residential roofing, gutters, and siding — plus a community-focused approach that many Peoria homeowners trust. If you want a local contractor who emphasizes craftsmanship, clear communication, and storm-response, Cupples is built to deliver that experience. Cupples Construction and Roofing+1
Why Cupples as #1: local responsiveness across Central Illinois, GAF Master Elite credential, family-owned accountability, and positive community presence. (Use this as your primary CTA: link to your Peoria roofing services page above.) Cupples Construction and Roofing
2) Kreiling Roofing Company
Website: https://www.kreiling.com/
Kreiling is a longstanding Peoria name — serving the area since 1921 with residential and commercial roofing crews, 24/7 emergency services, and a large local workforce. Their long tenure and robust local operations make them a major competitor for any sizeable roofing job in Peoria. If you need decades of local experience and broad capacity, Kreiling is a strong choice. kreiling.com+1
3) River City Roofing Company
Website: https://www.rivercityroofs.com/
River City Roofing serves Peoria, emphasizes GAF/Master-level competence, storm restoration work, and both residential + commercial roofing services. They’re regionally focused and often show up in local review sites and business listings for Peoria roofing projects — ideal if you’re comparing local specialists for storm repairs and full replacements. rivercityroofs.com+1
4) Ray’s Renovations (Ray’s Renovations Co.)
Website: https://raysrenovationsil.com/
A veteran- and family-owned company active in Central Illinois for decades, Ray’s Renovations provides roofing, siding, gutters, and exterior remodeling — with a track record of servicing Peoria-area homeowners. Great for homeowners who prefer smaller, family-run teams that also handle siding and full exterior renovations along with roofing. Rays Renovations+1
5) Best Choice Roofing & Construction
Website: https://bestchoiceroofing.com/
Best Choice Roofing is a larger regional/national firm with local presence in Illinois. They promote free inspections, storm-response teams, and strong manufacturer relationships (useful for insurance work and warranty-backed installations). If you want a company that pairs national resources with local branches, Best Choice is worth getting a quote from. Best Choice Roofing+1
How we ranked (quick peek at methodology)
- Local presence & response — Can they respond quickly for storm damage? (Important in Peoria’s weather.)
- Credentials & manufacturer certifications — GAF Master Elite, BBB, etc. (these matter for warranties).
- Longevity & capacity — Years in business and number of crews.
- Reviews & business listings — Yelp/BBB/Angi/Google presence and responsiveness.
- Services offered — Full roof replacement, repair, commercial systems, gutters & siding.
Where evidence was publicly listed (company pages, BBB or local business listings), that influenced the order. For transparency, Cupples was chosen as #1 because of local focus, GAF Master Elite status, family-owned accountability, and targeted service area across Central Illinois.